Flat Rate vs. Interchange Plus: Which Pricing Model is Right for Your Business?

Of all the confusing parts of credit card processing, nothing impacts your bottom line more directly than the pricing model your processor uses. It’s the engine that determines your costs, yet it’s often buried in jargon and deliberately complex sales pitches.

You've likely heard terms like "Flat Rate" and "Interchange Plus," but what do they actually mean for your business? One promises radical simplicity, while the other offers total transparency. Choosing between them is one of the most critical decisions a merchant can make.

In this guide, we will pull back the curtain on these two dominant pricing models. We'll break down exactly how they work, the pros and cons of each, and help you confidently decide which structure is truly the best fit for your bottom line.

The Simple Approach: What is Flat Rate Pricing?

Flat Rate pricing is exactly what it sounds like: you pay one single, consistent "flat" rate for every single transaction. This is the model used by popular providers like Square and Stripe, who typically charge a rate such as 2.9% + 30¢ regardless of whether the customer uses a debit card, a standard Visa, or a high-end rewards card.

The Pros:

• Ultimate Simplicity: This is the main appeal. Your statements are incredibly easy to read, and you can predict your costs with a high degree of certainty. There are no surprises.

• Good for New or Micro-Businesses: If you're just starting out or process a very low volume of sales (e.g., under $5,000/month), the simplicity can be beneficial when you're juggling a hundred other things.

The Cons (The Hidden Cost of Simplicity):

• Lack of Transparency: You never see the true wholesale cost of any transaction. The processor bundles everything together, so you have no idea what the underlying costs are or how much of a markup you're paying.

• Almost Always More Expensive: This is the critical downside. The real cost to process a debit card might be less than 1%, while a premium rewards card could be over 3%. To protect themselves, the Flat Rate provider sets their single rate high enough to cover their most expensive transactions. This means every time a customer pays with a low-cost debit card, you are significantly overpaying, and the processor is making a massive profit on that spread. You lose out on all the potential savings from those less expensive transactions.

The Transparent Model: What is Interchange Plus Pricing?

Interchange Plus (often called "Cost Plus") is the most transparent and, for most businesses, the most cost-effective pricing model available. It works by separating the two main components of any processing fee.

• 1. The "Interchange" (The Wholesale Cost): This is the true, non-negotiable cost that the card-issuing banks and credit card brands (like Visa and Mastercard) charge to process a transaction. This rate changes for every single card type—a debit card has a very low interchange cost, while a premium business rewards card has a much higher one. With this model, we pass this true cost directly to you with no markup.

• 2. The "Plus" (The Processor's Markup): This is the small, fixed fee the processor (in this case, Savibren) adds for providing the service. It’s typically a very small percentage and/or a per-transaction fee. This is our only profit, and it's clearly disclosed on your statement.

The Pros:

• Total Transparency: You see the exact wholesale cost and our disclosed markup on every single transaction. This structure acts as a defense against hidden profit, making it impossible to pad your bill with the miscellaneous junk charges and "fluff fees" common in other models. At Savibren, we guarantee our 'Plus' is the only markup you'll ever see.

• Lower Overall Cost: Because you get the direct benefit of low-cost transactions (like debit and standard credit cards), your overall effective rate is almost always lower than a Flat Rate plan, especially as your business grows.

The Cons:

• Statements Can Look More Complex: Because every card type is listed with its true interchange cost, your monthly statement will have more line items than a simple Flat Rate statement. (A good partner will walk you through it so it's easy to understand).

• Slight Monthly Fluctuation: Your overall effective rate isn't fixed; it will vary slightly each month depending on the mix of cards your customers use. A month with more debit card sales will have a lower overall rate than a month with more rewards cards.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Which Model Wins?

To make the choice even clearer, let's put the two models side-by-side and see how they stack up on the factors that matter most to your business.

FeatureFlat Rate PricingInterchange Plus PricingTransparencyLow. All costs are bundled into one rate, hiding the processor's true markup.High. All wholesale costs and the processor's markup are clearly separated and itemized.Overall CostHigher. You overpay on low-cost debit cards to cover the processor's risk on expensive cards.Lower. You benefit from the true low cost of debit cards, leading to significant long-term savings.SimplicityHigh. Statements are very simple and easy to predict from month to month.Lower. Statements are more detailed, reflecting the true cost of each transaction type.Best For...New startups, hobby businesses, or merchants processing less than $5k/month.Any established or growing business looking to maximize savings and achieve true transparency.

Export to Sheets

Conclusion: Finding the Right Fit for You

When it comes to payment processing, the choice between Flat Rate and Interchange Plus boils down to a classic trade-off: paying a premium for simplicity versus achieving powerful savings through transparency. While a flat rate might feel easy, it often means you're leaving money on the table.

At Savibren, we believe our job is to find the best solution for you. While we can accommodate any pricing model, we strongly encourage transparent options like Interchange Plus that ensure fairness. However, for most businesses, our ultimate goal is to help you eliminate your processing fees entirely through our Dual Pricing program.

Are you wondering if "fluff fees" are hiding in your current merchant statement? They tend to blend in and can be hard to catch. I would strongly urge you to connect with me for a free statement analysis to find the fluff in your fees.

Ready to see what a truly fair partnership looks like? Request a free, no-obligation statement analysis today. We'll show you the real numbers and explore all your options—from transparent Interchange Plus to our fee-eliminating Dual Pricing program.